Read Ch. 4 - 6

Week #2- Merry

Week #2- Merry

by Christine Merry -
Number of replies: 5

-The inferences section in Ch. 6 stuck out to me.  What made an impact on you in these chapters?

-“Meaning does not reside in the text, it is not something to grasp.  Meaning is created in the interaction–the transaction between the words in the text and the thoughts in the mind of the reader.  Meaning is created.”--This is so important.   This is what we need to understand.  We need students to understand this.  We need to give kids the power to create meaning.  


-Struggling through a text- this was an incredibly powerful part of these chapters.  I need to do this more often and take note of how I work through a text.  For this essay I read and reread, took notes, questioned, made inferences, returned to the text, reread the essay in its entirety. I plan to use difficult passages with the whole class.  I am going to model the struggle and teach them how to struggle.  I will ask them to do this whole group, small group, with partners and individually.  We will work on showing the internal work. Although I already do most of this, I have not focused on the internal work.  The internal work is going to be something I focus on more from now on.  


-How do you respond to students “who don’t get it”?

When students say, “I don’t get it!” I always ask them to be specific, whether Reading, Math, etc.  We break down the process to find the last step that worked and then move forward, or backward, from there.  I will continue to do this.  I always tell my kids that we can’t fix the problem until we know there is a problem.  We then need to name it or describe it so that we can make a plan to fix it.  


-Comprehension, understanding, and change is the goal of any reading.  What will you do differently in your teaching after reading this section?

On page 56 it states, “When we infer, we visualize; we make connections; we predict; we monitor our understanding; we summarize.”  These are strategies that Debbie Miller discusses at length in Reading with Meaning: Teaching Comprehension in the Primary Grades.  Stephanie Harvey and Anne Goudvis write about these strategies in Strategies that Work: Teaching Comprehension to Enhance UnderstandingComprehension Connections: Bridges to Strategic Reading by Tanny McGregor is a book that covers all of these.  These are all books that I own. I have read and reread these books.  These are all authors that I admire. I have used their ideas, lessons, strategies, anchor chart examples and mentor texts when teaching comprehension.  I used to teach a whole unit based on all of these strategies.  I felt like it really helped my kids.  I am going to add this unit back into my teaching during the first 20 days.  I’ll add it back in for whole group, strategy group, guided group and  for individuals. I will revisit as needed.

I am going to make adjustments when helping students with inferencing.  The tips and resources in the appendices will be very helpful!!



In reply to Christine Merry

Re: Week #2- Merry

by Erin Gray -
"We will work on showing the internal work." I cannot wait to model and work through this strategy with the students. We rarely turn to difficult passages and what a great way to show our readers how to engage with texts that are beyond them and their experiences.

Also, thank you for bringing up Debbie Miller's Reading with Meaning (Have you ordered the second addition, yet? lol). I remember getting so much out of this book and have been implementing those reading comprehension strategies ever since. Seeing that current authors/professionals like Kylene Beers still agree and are implementing many of the same techniques is such a nice change from yet another author reinventing the wheel, telling us that once again we're approaching this ever evolving field of teaching incorrectly.
In reply to Erin Gray

Re: Week #2- Merry

by Christine Merry -
"Also, thank you for bringing up Debbie Miller's Reading with Meaning (Have you ordered the second addition, yet? lol)"- Did you really ask that question?? I have had the second edition for years. I'll bring it to school if you'd like.
In reply to Christine Merry

Re: Week #2- Merry

by Hunter Dewey -
I like your response to students saying, "I don't get it!" How do you handle the students who say "I do not understand any of it." I tried having students ask specific questions. The students that can pinpoint the issue usually receive better assistance with a specific question. It is a great skill set for students to pinpoint what they are not understanding to complete the task or reading.
In reply to Christine Merry

Re: Week #2- Merry

by Wendy Rufa -
I own and reread these same books that you mention above, and, like you they changed the way I teach. I also love the first edition of "When Kids Can't Read..." but really appreciate this edition with it's updates. It's also a powerful reminder of our mission as teachers.
In reply to Christine Merry

Re: Week #2- Merry

by Ginny Reome -
I want my students to be specific when telling me what they do not understand and this chapter has given me as their mentor a way to name what they don't understand in text. I am going to compile text with clear examples of each type of inference and model my internal thinking for the students. Students will then practice with me, with their partners, and finally independently. I hope this work of naming what is not understood and struggling through the reading together will help students see that reading takes work and that is okay.