Prologue & Chapters 1 - 3

Wells Week 1

Wells Week 1

by Peggy Wells -
Number of replies: 4

Reading takes work and since the work goes “underground” the concept becomes daunting for students who need to work harder than others because it is not a visual process.  How do we impress upon all students that reading at any age takes practice and work?

Working with struggling readers, I often see them frustrated when they cannot read when they are in the older elementary grades.  I try to encourage them that we all struggle with things, we just can't give up and keep trying.  I am an avid reader and will share some of my struggles I encounter while reading, such as an unfamiliar word and how I look the word up if I can't figure out the meaning from context clues.  I certainly would struggle too if I had to read and understand a medical text book or law book, so as adults there are things we struggle with too.  

-What stood out to you  in these chapters?

A few things stood out to me.  I think it is great this book addresses the need to stop teaching to a test.  When districts are putting more emphasis on a test score, it makes it difficult to be able to teach the students to become independent thinkers because the teachers feel the pressure to make sure the students are learning what they need to pass a test rather than what the students need.  

Another thing that stood out to me was the difference between responsible readers and responsive readers.  Responsible readers are surface readers while a responsive reader dives deeper.  I find I struggle with getting my students to become more responsive and I hope to learn more strategies to help in this area.   

-How does the Science of Reading impact your instruction? (regardless of content area)

In my classroom, I provide instruction on phonological awareness, phonics and word recognition on a daily basis.  Due to the students I work with, we embed vocabulary and fluency instruction as we can.  I try to focus on the phonological awareness and phonics the most because of the needs of my students.  

-What skills are important to be able to read?

I really like figure 3.1 skilled and less skilled readers, it is really a great list to see the differences between what a skilled reader can do and a less skilled reader struggles with.  I think all those skills are important to be able to read, and as the author said there are probably more skills that are not on the list.  I can see so many of my students skills and needs on both lists.  

In reply to Peggy Wells

Re: Wells Week 1

by Ginny Reome -
I struggle with getting students to be responsive readers as well. It is important to practice this skill and one way to accomplish this with our students is through read aloud books as students do not have to spend a lot of energy decoding words.
In reply to Peggy Wells

Re: Wells Week 1

by Hunter Dewey -
Hello Peggy,

I agree with the issue of teaching to the test. However, the teachers and students feel pressured to do well on the NYS Regents and state tests. I like how you call responsible readers, "surface readers" since they are just getting the gist and being done with it. This doesn't allow for deeper learning.

We both share that students skills are on both lists. I thinker it is harder at the high school level to have student enjoy reading when there are many other things they are doing with clubs and sports.

I think it is a good idea to showcase to students that even teachers struggle with certain types of books because of interests or subject. I can read a lot of types of non-fiction, you give me fiction then I usually struggle to engage with the reading.
In reply to Peggy Wells

Re: Wells Week 1

by Deleted user -
I agree that teaching to test should no longer be our priority. We understand that as special education teacher our priority isn't the test but the student success. I also think their successes can come in small doses and we should celebrate even the littlest of them.
In reply to Peggy Wells

Re: Wells Week 1

by Nikki Phippen -
I also liked how this book points out the need to stop teaching to the test and that the high stakes test that the state makes our students take are not appropriate indicators of what the students can or cannot do. I agree that many of my students are also responsible readers and it is hard to get them to be more responsive.